
I like to imagine that J.R.R. Tolkien and C.S. Lewis are totally best friends forever (literally forever since it is the afterlife after all) and hang out all the time up in heaven. I also like to imagine that they get to see the movies based on their books at the same time we do, of which they would obviously have opinions about. Here is how I imagine things going:
Lewis: So the DVD for Voyage of the Dawn Treader came out on Friday.
Tolkien: Oh yeah? The DVDs for Lord of the Rings is coming out on a few months.
Lewis: I thought they came out already?
Tolkien: No, those were the DVDs, these are the blu-rays or some shit like that. I don’t really get technology. I thought a pixel was a piece of fairydust since about a week ago.
Lewis: No, I know. But I thought the blu-rays came out already.
Tolkien: No, those were the theatrical editions. These are the extended editions.
Lewis: Oooh, yeah, that bullshit. Yeah, they tried pulling that extended edition crap with the Narnia movies. They added – like – eight minutes. Didn’t really fly. Probably because the Narnia movies are crap.
Tolkien: Well not as bad as the Lord of the Rings movies, surely.
Lewis: Are you fucking kidding me? The Lord of the Rings won oscars! The Narnia movies are like the retarded cousin of the Harry Potter movies.
Tolkien: Oh, don’t even get me started on that Rowling bitch. Dementors! FUCKING DEMENTORS! If ever I saw a wraith ripoff in my afterlife, it was those fuckers.
Lewis: I know! And none of her animals talked. What the shit was up with that?
Tolkien: Well yeah, whatever. Talking animals. (cough)
Lewis: Shut up! Talking animals are relevant!
Tolkien: Right. (cough) Anyway, did you even see the Lord of the Rings movies? They were utter bullshit. They got everything wrong! And they cut out Tom Bombadil!
Lewis: thankgod.
Tolkien: What did you say?
Lewis: Nothing. But at least they got your main characters right! Aslan was supposed to be the size of an elephant in Prince Caspian. AN ELEPHANT! How can you take a talking capital L Lion seriously if it’s just a normal sized lion?
Tolkien: youcanttakeanytalkinganimalseriously.
Lewis: What?
Tolkien: Nothing. Besides! They got my most main character all wrong too! Frodo is an adult in the series! He’s older than the other hobbits for a reason! Frodo and Sam’s relationship is supposed to be reminiscent of a World War One army officer and their servant! And they totally blew it! And Elijah Fucking Wood has got to be the worst actor on the face of the planet. Did you see both times he passed out? DID YOU FUCKING SEE THAT?! He went on for about 15 minutes before he finally keeled over! Even I was rooting for him to die!
Lewis: Yeah, and then maybe one of the eagles could’ve just taken the ring to Mordor instead.
Tolkien: Oh fuck you, I’m not justifying the stupid eagle shit again. Everyone thinks they’re so fucking original by asking why the fucking eagles didn’t just take the ring to Mordor. Just give it a rest people!
Lewis: Seems like someone’s overcompensating for a bit of writer’s regret.
Tolkien: The Horse and His Boy.
Lewis: Oh shut up. Back to my original point, I have two words for you: Helm’s Deep.
Tolkien: Okay, yeah, that was pretty badass. But seriously, Legolas skateboarding down the stairs? When I saw that for the first time, I started spinning for no reason, and then I realized it was because I was turning over in my grave!
Lewis: At least your characters did something cool! The only cool character in the Narnia movies was the White Witch, and she’s the bad guy! And a woman! Ugh. They even crammed her into the second two movies even though she wasn’t in those books!
Tolkien: But Reepicheep! That little fucker was slicing peoples throats in a PG movie! That is – like – the definition of cool!
Lewis: Yeah, but they couldn’t even get the same guy to voice him in both movies! Oh, are you too busy to do a little voice work Izzard? Not too busy to dress up in women’s clothing though, eh?!
Tolkien and Lewis: And they kept showing us instead of telling! JINX!
Tolkien: They actually showed us the ents storming Isengard instead of just hearing about it in an extended dialog weeks later! Where’s the art in that?!
Lewis: They did that with the end of the first movie too! Who wants to be in the middle of an exciting battle when you can hear someone tell you about it later on?!
Tolkien: I know!
Lewis: Well it seems as though we’re at an impasse.
Tolkien: Hey, there’s a Harry Potter marathon on, wanna watch?
Lewis: Fuck yeah. Is it pre or post Hot Hermione?
Tolkien: There’s a pre?
END SCENE