
So I saw Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1 this weekend. When I first heard they were splitting up the last book into two movies, I was pissed. I figured that it was just another way for movie studios to take our money. (Have I mentioned they only released the theatrical cuts of Lord of the Rings on blu-ray even though the extended editions have been out for years? Hoping that poor saps will once again double dip with their purchases. Well I’m not one of them! Bitter much? Maybe.)
Anyway, my initial concerns were eased a bit when I heard where they were splitting things up. It sounded like a solid place to split up the movie, not leaving things with too much of a cliffhanger like… Voldemort places his wang wand against Harry’s forehead… “Avada…!” CUT TO BLACK.
How much would that suck?
Like I said in my last post, my hope was that years from now, you’d be able to watch and enjoy this movie on it’s own. But anyway, enough about me and my stupid concerns, how was it?
It was fantastic of course. Just like everyone says it is. It’s a beautiful movie to look at, and all the kids perform admirably. They were able to trim down the wandering in the forest yelling at each other from the book and turn it into a compelling story to watch. Yes, it’s sad watching them fight, but it never gets to the point where it’s annoying to watch.
It’s not a particularly fun movie to watch though. Besides some brief laughs and a really fun moment between Harry and Hermione, the whole thing is a bit glum. That’s not so much a complaint, but a worry that in the years to come, I’m not going to be picking up this movie at a bar for a good time. I think a large part of that has to do with the lack of a climactic battle at the end.
My favorite movies in the series Prisoner of Azkaban and Order of the Phoenix have these fantastic final battles and climaxes. Just like Half Blood Prince, that doesn’t really happen here. People like to compare this with The Empire Strikes Back. And yes, the three of them have pretty sad cliffhanger endings, it doesn’t mean we didn’t get to watch Luke and Vader try and kill each other for 20 minutes first. I think the filmmakers are trying so hard to let us know that the bad guys are winning that they think that means leaving out any battle whatsoever.
The final battle of The Deathly Hallows – Part 1 stuck close to the book, but I was hoping that since they were splitting up the movie there that they’d amp up the action a bit more to get our hearts racing. I don’t mean it as that much of a complaint, but like Half Blood Prince, while it’s amazing to watch, it’s also a bit flat.
But that’s it. Maybe I’m just supposed to get over myself and view Parts 1 and 2 as one big movie. Lord knows there’s should be battles galore in the next one to get my heart racing. Overall this was another amazing addition to the Harry Potter franchise.